Three models, one deliberate choice
Bookings only
Every table can be booked, online or by phone. It is the most predictable model: you know the night before how many covers to expect and order accordingly. The risk: turning walk-ins away on nights when some bookings do not show, and looking out of reach to people passing by.
Walk-ins only
No bookings: first come, first served. It works for a counter, a busy neighbourhood spot or a place with a queue outside. But you lose guests who like to plan: groups, special occasions, people coming from further away. And the room can stay empty on a rainy night with no warning.
The mix
Some tables are bookable, the others are kept for walk-ins. Many independent restaurants choose this, because it gives visibility without closing the door. The craft lies in setting the proportion, and in changing it from one service to the next.
Revenue management research has long pointed out what reservations bring: they help a restaurant choose its customer mix and manage its time. Walk-ins bring flexibility and the unexpected guest. The mix tries to get both.
Who your walk-ins are
Before setting a number, look at who comes in without a booking. The profile changes from one service to another:
- weekday lunch: people working nearby, who decide at 11:50 and have an hour;
- tourists and visitors: they stroll, read the menu in the window, come in if a table is free;
- the terrace or patio in good weather: people sit down because the sun is out and a spot is free (see our article on terrace and patio bookings);
- late evening: after a show or a drink, unplanned.
A station brasserie and a village restaurant do not see the same walk-ins. That is why the proportion is set in your restaurant, not in an article. Where tourists matter, see also how to take bookings from international guests without speaking their language and the hotels and tourist offices that send you guests.
How many tables to hold back
Measure first
The only sound method is to count. For three or four weeks, note at every service how many covers arrived without a booking and how many guests you turned away for lack of space. Alongside, note the booked covers. You get, service by service, the real share of walk-ins.
A starting point, then adjust
As an illustration, if your counts show that a quarter of lunch covers arrive without a booking, keep about a quarter of lunch seats out of online booking, and almost none on Saturday night if it is all booked ahead. Then adjust in small steps:
- walk-in tables empty service after service? Make one bookable online;
- walk-ins turned away while booked tables sit empty late? Take one out of online booking.
Review the proportion every season: the terrace or patio, school holidays and bank or public holidays all shift it.
The phone and the team keep control
A table that is not bookable online is not off-limits for bookings. Your team can still give it to a regular who calls, or keep it free for walk-ins. The setting shields these tables from automatic online bookings; you decide the rest.
Which tables to hold back
Not every table suits walk-ins. The best candidates:
- the bar or counter and high tables: guests settle in fast, for a dish or a drink, and leave;
- small tables near the door: passers-by see them, and the team seats them without crossing the room;
- the terrace or patio, at least in part: it depends on the weather and draws people walking by;
- two-tops: most walk-ins come alone or in pairs.
Keep in booking the large tables and table combinations, which need planning, and the corner tables people book for an occasion. Your floor plan is the right place to decide, table by table.
Record walk-ins too
A walk-in recorded nowhere does not exist in your numbers. You will never know whether the proportion was right, or how many covers walk-ins really bring. So record every walk-in in the same list as your bookings, as you seat them: covers, time, table.
The habit has two other benefits. Your service plan stays accurate: if your tool knows every occupied table, it will not offer online the one a walk-in has just taken. And you measure how long meals really last, which helps you set table turns and service durations.
With gonnabook.it, any table or room can be set as not bookable online in the floor-plan editor, and a walk-in is recorded as “Walk-in” in the same list as the service’s bookings.
Say it, on Google and on your website
Guests often look for the answer before they come: “Do I need to book?” Say it clearly:
- on your website, next to the booking button: “We always keep a few tables for walk-ins”;
- on your Google Business Profile, in the description and, where your category offers them, in the attributes: Google notes that some attributes are only available in certain countries or categories (see our article on your Google Business Profile);
- on the door or in the window, with your opening hours.
A passer-by who knows they have a chance walks in more readily. A guest who knows Saturday night books up, books.
Frequently asked questions
Should a restaurant hold tables for walk-ins?
It is a business choice, not an obligation. Keeping a few tables out of online booking lets you welcome passers-by, lunchtime workers and tourists instead of turning them away. The right share depends on your location and the service: measure it by counting, for a few weeks, the covers that arrive without a booking and the guests you have to turn away.
Which tables are best for walk-ins?
Ideally the ones you can seat quickly and that people see from the street: the bar or counter, high tables, small two-tops near the door and part of the terrace or patio. Large tables, table combinations and corner tables suit bookings better, because they need planning or tend to be chosen for a special occasion.
Why record walk-ins in the booking system?
To know what walk-ins really bring and to set the share of tables on facts rather than impressions. Recorded in the same list as bookings, a walk-in table is no longer offered online by a tool that sees the whole room, and you can measure how long meals actually last. Without that record, walk-ins stay invisible in your numbers.
Sources
- Sheryl E. Kimes, Customer Attitudes towards Restaurant Reservations Policies, Journal of Revenue and Pricing Management, vol. 10, no. 3, 2011, Cornell University.
- Google Business Profile Help, Manage your business attributes, attributes available by country and category.
- Google Business Profile Help, Manage your local business links, the profile’s booking link.
- The example with numbers (a quarter of lunch covers arriving without a booking) is an illustration, not a statistic.